The rules have changed
Is social media dying? No. But it's certainly evolving, and we're still waiting to see what that final metamorphosis will look like.
Social media began as a place to connect with friends and family. To share your thoughts out loud for those willing to listen. MySpace, Facebook and Bebo were all open spaces to communicate and engage with each other. For brands, it was an exciting opportunity to reach audiences in new ways, share products and announcements, and build genuine connections.
And it worked like that for a while… until it didn't.
Now, the model is cracking. Our platforms have become algorithmically supercharged, leading to fragmented audiences, eroding trust, and feeds once relied upon by brands now increasingly flooded with bots and AI spam.
What comes next is still taking shape. But the direction is clear: smaller, more intentional, more human.
The brands that understand this shift and the real challenges it brings will be the ones that stay relevant in 2026, and more importantly, help social media reconnect with its origin story.
The reality check
Last month, we put AI to the test vs my own social media expertise. The question we asked was ‘what's the biggest social media challenge in 2026 - in just two words?'
The single lens that united all of the responses (including mine) was realness.
Every challenge posed was essentially a different symptom of the same crisis: audiences can no longer tell what's genuine. Whether that's content, accounts, brands or information.
And the response to that crisis, from both audiences and platforms, is to reward what feels authentically human and creatively distinct.
In a landscape drowning in AI-generated noise and eroding trust, the scarcest commodity on social media in 2026 isn't reach or budget. Its credibility. And the only way brands earn this is through creativity and content that genuinely connects and builds a community.
Unpicking the challenges and the brands that are getting it right
You’ve got trust issues
Every day, social teams are trying to build successful platforms and demand engagement from their audience. But building relationships with audiences who are increasingly sceptical of everything they see online is a huge challenge.
It's no longer enough to show up consistently. Users are actively questioning whether the brand behind the content is genuine, whether the reviews are real, and whether the engagement is human.
For a social team, that means every piece of content carries an extra burden: it has to prove the brand is worth trusting before it can even begin to sell, and most brands skip this section entirely and jump straight into selling.
The brands that didn’t buy trust, they built it:
North Bar - Rather than seeing themselves purely as a beer brand, North Bar views its bars as living, breathing things and has built a cult following not just in the North where it originated, but across the UK, distributing its beers nationwide. Their social media community is fiercely loyal and celebrates their northern roots while partnering with other brew legends across the country and the world. They don't perform authenticity. They just are it.
Oatly- A bold brand with a direct and honest approach and a clear purpose-led business. They’re passionately purpose-led as a business and speak to a community that cares just as much about the environment as they do. Through consistent and meaningful dedication to the cause, they’ve now earned the right to share content about their products with their community alongside their bigger mission to help their community live healthier lives.
Paris 2024 won a D&AD Black Pencil in Graphic Design for "Designing Paris 2024". The campaign reimagined the visual identity of the Olympic Games to unify heritage with sport, acting as a catalyst for changing a city's attitude and behaviour. Sadly, the IOC deleted the official @paris2024 Instagram account last year, losing valuable cultural narrative and content.
AI content fatigue
The problem AI has created for social teams isn’t just ethical; it’s the onslaught of sameness saturating feeds. Savvy audiences are sharper than ever at spotting AI-generated content, and platforms are responding. Rather than rewarding it, algorithms are starting to deprioritise repetitive, synthetic output in favour of work that feels authentic, human, and unique.
Therefore, for brands that lean too heavily on AI to produce content at volume, the result is a feed that looks busy but performs badly. The deeper issue is that every AI-generated post a brand publishes chips away at the very thing audiences are hungry for…proof that there's a real human on the other side of the screen who actually gives a damn.
The brands that didn't take the easy route
A$AP Rocky won a D&AD Black Pencil in Music Videos for "Tailor Swif" which was shared across social and recognised for its long-form storytelling and narrative. The video reflected a shift in how digital content and music can engage audiences, and was lauded for its "unmistakably human" approach.
Poppi: A brand fully embedded in the experience. Their founder, Allison Ellsworth, started at a farmers' market and is now one of the top-selling soft drink brands on Amazon. Her commitment to working with real humans through influencer marketing was reported in 2023 to amount to 204 million impressions and 2.3 million engagements.
Surreal: A bold brand shaking up the FMCG market. Surreal could have used AI for their out-of-home advertising campaigns, but instead, invested in the real thing and reused the billboards for online content, creating viral conversations.
Creativity: the real human issue
We’ve lost what it means to be social… on social media. Where once you saw friends, families and brands that you followed, intent-based feeds, you now see what the algorithm decides you want to see, interest-based feeds.
That changes everything for brands, because you're no longer guaranteed an audience even among people who actively chose to follow you.
The creative implication of that is huge: your content now has to earn its place in a feed it was never promised a place in. It's competing not just against other brands, but against every piece of content the algorithm has decided matches that user's interests.
So the creative challenge isn't just "make good content." Its content is good enough to stop someone mid-scroll who may have never heard of you, in a feed curated entirely around their personal behaviour.
That's a genuinely difficult brief. And it connects directly back to the authenticity crisis because the content that tends to win in interest-based feeds is content that feels native, human and real. Not polished brand output, not brands that are just trying to sell, not AI-generated nonsense. What wins is content that genuinely resonates and connects with the community it is trying to build.
The brands that stopped the scroll:
Spotify won a D&AD Black Pencil for "Spreadbeats" in the Digital Marketing/Digital Design category. The campaign used an Excel spreadsheet as a creative medium, hacking into digital spaces to promote Spotify’s ad offerings, demonstrating a highly innovative use of digital technology to shift perceptions of B2B advertising.
Wet Leg: Their unique and quirky sense of humour isn’t just felt through their music; it’s a core part of their social media interaction. Tongue-in-cheek responses to comments show their personality rather than trying to promote their music, and the algorithm rewards them for being genuinely connected and real with their followers.
Remember the origin story
The brands that are winning on social in 2026 aren't necessarily the ones with the biggest budgets, the slickest production or the most sophisticated AI tools.
They're the ones who remembered what social media was supposed to be in the first place, a place to connect, to communicate and to build something real with the people paying attention.
Social media isn't dying. But the version of it that served as a shortcut for brands (guaranteed reach, passive audiences, content on autopilot) that is.
What's replacing it looks a lot more like what social was always supposed to be. Smaller. More intentional. More human.
The brands that will matter in 2026 and beyond won't be the ones that post the most. They'll be the ones that meant something to someone. And in 2026, that's the most radical thing a brand can do on social media.
If your social media feels lost in the noise, it’s time for a human-first approach. Let’s build a strategy that earns trust, drives engagement and growth. Get in touch today.
.jpg)
